Three Questions for an Editor: Crown’s Roger Scholl on A MOTHER’S RECKONING
May 12, 2016
Roger Scholl, Vice President, Executive Editor, Crown Publishing Group, delves inside the acquisition, editing and impact of A MOTHER’S RECKONING: Living in the Aftermath of Tragedy by Sue Klebold, the mother of Columbine shooter Dylan Klebold.
What was involved in the acquisition of this book and key decisions about how to tell and structure this heart-breaking, tragic story?
I first heard of the book as the result of a lunch date with the agent, Laurie Bernstein, two years before the actual submission. Sue Klebold’s story, and message, sounded so unique, and so important, that I followed up periodically to express continued interest. Laurie gave me a heads up a week before she sent it out, and I alerted our publisher and the rest of our team that it was coming in, so that we would read and act quickly. The proposal came in the Thursday evening of BEA; I was expected at a reunion party, but I never made it – I was glued to my desk and my computer. The proposal, over 100 pages in length, was stunning — and pitch perfect in conveying Sue and her family’s experiences, and her ultimate message. And we made a pre-emptive bid for the book by noon the next day.
How would you describe the editor/author editorial process and what were some of the most challenging and rewarding points during the creation of A MOTHER’S RECKONING?
Sue had been teamed with a wonderful writer for the book, Laura Tucker. The proposal was so taut, so nuanced, and so well constructed that my real task as an editor with the manuscript was to ensure that we maintained the same high level of narrative pacing, detail, insight and candor that Sue and Laurie had originally achieved with the proposal. We did a good deal of back and forth to tighten the narrative, and made a few key decisions about structure and order, as well as about the level of detail Sue included in the book about the events at Columbine High School that morning, so that readers unfamiliar with the details of the tragedy would have a clearer picture of exactly what took place – and what Dylan, Sue’s son, and Eric Harris, did.
What do you and Ms. Klebold hope readers will derive most from reading and discussing this book?
I think that for Sue, this book has been a mission. She has spent every day of her life since the shootings trying to understand how the sweet young boy that she knew Dylan to be could have done what he did; why she was unable to see the signs beforehand; what she might have done differently to prevent the tragedy. The media wanted to paint Dylan as a monster. But the truth, she knew, was in some ways even more disturbing. He grew up in a loving, engaged home, had many friends, and although he was shy and perhaps spent too much time on his computer, he came across as a normal teenager, a boy who had just gone to senior prom and had been accepted to his first choice college. Her husband, Tom – they are now divorced – and her surviving son Bryon, were deeply opposed to her writing the book; it was just too painful a memory, and one I think they did not want to live through again. But Sue persevered because she felt that by telling her story, and the story of Dylan, she could reach out to parents and kids who were suffering emotionally or psychologically, and at risk, and in doing so potentially prevent a future Columbine from taking place, or prevent a child from hurting himself or herself, or someone else. Sue is donating the money she has received to charitable organizations, particularly those focused on mental health issues. Popular Company News
A Newly Discovered and Never-Before-Seen Manuscript by Dr. Seuss To Be Published by Random House Children’s Books
October 28, 2025
An original manuscript and cover sketch by Ted Geisel, aka Dr. Seuss, was discovered in the archives of UC San Diego’s Geisel Library, and will be…
Our Five Finalists for the 2025 National Book Awards
October 7, 2025
Today, the National Book Foundation, a nonprofit organization, announced the finalists for the 76th National Book Awards. Established in 1950, the National Book Awards are American literary prizes…
Random House Children’s Books to Acquire Cherry Lake Publishing Group
November 11, 2025
Sleeping Bear Press, Tilbury House, and Other Cherry Lake Imprints to Join Random House Children’s Books, Maintaining Distinct Identities and Leadership. Random House Children’s Books (RHCB),…
Penguin Random House and United for Libraries Announce 2026 Grant Program for Rural and Small Libraries
October 21, 2025
Penguin Random House and United for Libraries have announced a 2026 grant program designed to uplift rural and small libraries across the country. This initiative will…
Dayton Literary Peace Prize 2025: Salman Rushdie Wins Distinguished Achievement Award & MARTYR! Wins Fiction Award
September 30, 2025
The Dayton Literary Peace Prize is the first and only annual U.S. literary award recognizing the power of the written word to promote peace. Prize nominations include…
Reading Rainbow Returns After 20 Years With Penguin Random House Author Mychal Threets as Host
October 3, 2025
After a nearly 20-year absence, Reading Rainbow will return with a new series on the YouTube channel KidZuko, hosted by Mychal Threets, Penguin Random House author and Mychal the…
Spotlighting Our Titles on Amazon’s Best Books of 2025
November 14, 2025
Amazon recently released its Best Books of 2025 list, compiled by the Amazon Editors after spending thousands of hours reading and evaluating an impressive range of…
Higher Ground to Launch “IMO: The Look” Podcast Series With Michelle Obama on November 5, Featuring Live Events Alongside Book Release
October 16, 2025
Higher Ground, the media company founded by President Barack Obama and Michelle Obama, today announced a special six-part limited companion series to its hit podcast IMO…
David Szalay Wins the 2025 Booker Prize for FLESH
November 12, 2025
We’re thrilled to share that David Szalay has won the 2025 Booker Prize, one of the leading literary awards in the English-speaking world, for his novel…
